A message to American Jewry: Aliyah is your battle in our war. COME HOME.
B"SD - 24 Adar - Friday, March 8
My name is Yehuda Potaznik. Up until a few months ago I lived on the
Upper East Side, learned in Ramaz, and attended services in KJ. Today, I
am writing to you from my new, true Home. Since the beginning of the
year, I have been studying in a Hesder Yeshiva located in the middle of
the Hebron Hills, the heart of Judea. In this particular area Avraham
and the other patriarchs traveled from Be'er Sheva to Hevron and Har
Ha'Moriah, Otniel ben Knaz ruled over the people of Israel, King David
raised his sheep, and today many brave Jews live and study amongst an
extremely hostile population.
As we all know, the past year and a half in Israel has been extremely
difficult; especially in the West Bank and Gaza. The worst thing,
however, is the psychological effect of this continuous terror war. When
literally every day one hears about the settler that was killed here, the
bomb that killed commuters in the city over there, the policeman killed
at this
checkpoint, the soldiers ambushed at that checkpoint, one develops this
kind of apathy that is a mixture of general despair with an actual loss
of concern. However, every once in a while an attack occurs which hits
home and reminds us of the reality and pain of this war which we are
fighting. For me, the attack last night on a Yeshiva in the Gaza strip
was one of these. Some time before midnight a lone terrorist crossed the
fence of the community
of Atzmona. When reaching the caravans, sleeping quarters, of the
Mechina, a pre-army yeshiva located there, the terrorist began firing at
anyone in sight, picking out caravans which were lit or from which he
heard music being played. He then proceeded on to the Beit Midrash,
where a shiur was being given by one of the Rabbanim, and continued
spraying bullets and hurling grenades. The event lasted a total of
twenty minutes until the terrorist was shot down and had left behind some
30 injured students, including around a dozen very serious injuries.
Five of the boys were soon reported dead. In one story I heard, one of
the students was in his room when he heard the terrorist open fire. The
student went outside to see what was happening and was then noticed by
the terrorist who started chasing him back into his room.
The boy managed to turn off the lights and find a hiding spot before the
terrorist came in after him, spraying the room with gunfire. When I hear
this description, I can't help but picture my own Yeshiva. Our caravans
are similarly located next to the security fence and just beyond the
caravans, on the top of the hill, sits the Beit Midrash. There have been
times while laying down in bed or performing shmira (guard duty) in the
middle of the night that I have contemplated such a scenario occurring in
my own Yeshiva. It could. This sad event has reminded me that the war
being fought here is all too real. These are not just statistics. Being
that I am in an Israeli yeshiva, many of my friends know guys who learn
in Atzmona. Today, over half of my class left Yeshiva to attend the
funerals or visit their friends in the hospital. Earlier this week, one
of my roommates went to the funeral of his
former Bnei Akiva counselor who was killed in uniform during another
attack in Gaza. My other roommate from Efrat knew the woman who was
killed this week while driving in her car. My cousin works very close to
the cafe in Jerusalem where a bomb was successfully averted towards the
end of the week. This is all too real.
Now, why do I need to tell this to you? Though it may not feel like
it, it was not so long ago that I too was sitting in my comfy apartment
in New York. I know that when you're far away, living in a very
different environment, getting all of your news from NBC or CNN (which
don't report the dozens of non fatal attacks that occur daily), and when
you simply have no relationship to the victims, it is very easy to let
the situation turn into a bunch of sad data which you store somewhere
in the back of your head if not throw it out. But you can not let that
happen. You can not let the distance serve as an excuse, because the
truth is that it's really not that far away. When Jews in Israel are
being attacked, it is your family in your home that is being attacked.
These might sound like nice words of
propaganda, but these are the words of God, the words of our Torah. As
religious Jews, in particular, it has to be as real as anything. When a
Jew, a world, is destroyed, you should be able to feel the pain as real
as if you would have a knife stabbed into your own right arm. I'm not
saying that people should go around being depressed all day long, but you
have to make an effort to make it part of your daily reality and
consciousness.
There is more to it though. This is a war. It's a war that is being
fought on more than just one type of battlefield, and it must be fought
back on all of the appropriate battlefields. The enemy, in this case,
wants us to live in fear in our own land. Better yet, it does not want
us to live at all in our own land. As scary as it is, the people here
are not surrendering. The settlers of the West Bank and Gaza, who have
probably suffered the most, are stronger in their will than ever. The
people of Jerusalem continue to take to the streets and go about their
daily lives. They are fighting on the front lines. This is not the time
for American Jews to take up seats in the bleachers. This is your war.
It is our war. Thank God, people are coming to Israel. I have met many
friends and parents of friends who came to visit this year. Last shabbat
I was at a Bar- Mitzvah of a family from the community in New York.
Communities, such as KJ, are sending solidarity missions. Many have even
come to visit the settlement communities, such as the one where I am
learning, and thousands of young people are here learning in Yeshivot.
But more people have to be coming. People should be coming to Israel in
the droves this Pesach and in the summer. Even that is not enough.
This might not be a popular statement to make, but NOW is the time for
a reawakening amongst American Jews to Aliyah. With a terror war and
many other difficulties taking place in Israel, NOW is the time for
American Jews, with their special traits and skills, to be building their
homes and contributing to the Jewish community IN Israel. As difficult
as it may seem, aliyah is needed now, because their is too much to lose
if we keep procrastinating. Let me ask you a question. If you had to
leave home for a while for whatever reasons, and after some time you
received news that some violent criminals had broken into your house and
were attacking your kids or your siblings, what would your reaction be?
Would you wait it out till the situation was safe? Would you come visit
for a few days, drop off gifts and goodies, wish them luck, and leave?
You'd probably take the first plane back, and without even thinking about
your own life would roll up your sleeves and join the fight. It is hard
to see the actual situation as such, but, once again, as religious Jews
we must realize that it is. When the Jewish community in its homeland is
under attack, it is halachikly defined as a milchemet mitzvah. That means
that it is every Jew's religious obligation to take up arms. If one is
not capable of actually joining the IDF, than
there are other means of doing so in the current situation. While you are
in America anyway, demonstrations and other forms of support are
important, but the even greater importance of fighting the war from
within Israel must be thought of and taken more seriously than ever.
Keep in mind that it must be the religious- Zionist communities, in
particular, that lead the way.
I say these words to you not as my own, but as the clear message of
our Torah and national history during these hard times. I pray with you
for better times and for the ultimate redemption, may it be soon.
B'ahavat Yisrael,
Yehuda Potaznik